Hospital preventive teams not saving lives: study

By Julie Steenhuysen

CHICAGO (Reuters) - Special teams set up to spot patients at risk of having cardiac or respiratory arrests in U.S. hospitals do not save lives and may not be a good use of resources, researchers said on Tuesday.

The teams are not “crash” teams that swoop in to revive patients but rather experts in identifying people likely to suffer often-fatal cardiac or respiratory arrests, to save both lives and costs.

Dr. Paul Chan of the University of Missouri in Kansas City and colleagues studied whether such rapid response teams helped reduce hospital-wide incidents of cardiopulmonary arrest and death rates.

“It’s not harming people but there is not a clear additional benefit,” said Chan, whose study appears in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Rapid response teams are one of six recommendations made by the non-profit Institute for Healthcare Improvement or IHI as part of a push to cut preventable deaths and improve quality.

The special multidisciplinary teams are devoted to quickly identifying at-risk patients and moving them into a higher level of care, such as the intensive care unit, where they can be better monitored.

Chan said hospitals have widely adopted this practice with little evidence to suggest they help save lives.

He and colleagues looked to see whether the adoption of such a team in 2005 helped prevent cardiac and respiratory arrests at Saint Luke’s Hospital in Kansas City. They compared hospital records on 24,193 admissions before the teams were put in place and nearly 25,000 after they were put in place.

While they saw fewer efforts to revive patients from cardiac and respiratory arrest outside of the intensive care unit, the addition of the teams did not significantly reduce such efforts across the whole hospital.

Nor did they save more lives.

“Based on our sample size, there was not even a suggestion of a reduction of mortality at the level we would have hoped,” Chan said in a telephone interview.

Chan said the teams may have resulted in more families issuing “Do Not Resuscitate” or DNR orders that prohibit hospital staff from taking life-saving measures, but they were not able to track this.

Dr. Don Goldmann, senior vice president at IHI, noted that the researchers did see an overall decline in the need to revive patients from cardiac and respiratory arrests, a sign the teams were effective. “Whether it was statistically significant was inconclusive,” he said.

“Overall, we’re still extremely encouraged and think this is a sensible and logical approach to reducing cardiac and respiratory arrests and avoiding unnecessary deaths,” Goldmann said in a telephone interview.

Chan said a larger study in more hospitals might yet prove the teams benefit patients.  Continued…


Related Posts:

By Julie Steenhuysen CHICAGO (Reuters) - Implantable heart defibrillators — which have been found to save lives in younger patients — appear to have the same benefit for people over 70, U.S. researchers said on Tuesday. The study suggests the devices, known as implantable cardioverter defibrillators or ICDs, should be offered to people in their 70s despite

Full Post: Implantable defibrillators save older patients too

GENEVA (Reuters) - Global recession may lead many governments to reduce investment in basic healthcare, putting at risk the lives of vulnerable mothers and babies, the World Health Organization (WHO) said on Monday. WHO Director-General Margaret Chan said the world’s economic woes could set back huge public health campaigns meant to eliminate diseases, tackle the root

Full Post: Recession raises risks for mothers, babies: WHO

By Michael Kahn LONDON (Reuters) - Five centuries after Leonardo da Vinci’s intricate drawings transformed understanding of the human heart, a new computer model promises to do the same for modern-day cardiac care, experts say. The model — so realistic its four chambers beat in the same asymmetrical rhythm on screen as does a real heart in

Full Post: New cyber heart model recalls da Vinci’s sketches

By Maggie Fox, Health and Science Editor WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A common and sometimes deadly cause of diarrhea is far more common in U.S. hospitals than people thought, and only better hygiene and more judicious use of antibiotics will help, experts reported on Tuesday. As many as 13 out of every 1,000 hospital patients are infected with

Full Post: Diarrhea bacteria common in hospitals: survey

By Maggie Fox, Health and Science Editor WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A simple checklist to confirm a patient’s name, what procedure is to be done, check allergies and count needles and sponges to make sure nothing got left inside halved the rate of surgery-related deaths, doctors reported on Wednesday. The checklist, similar to those used by pilots before

Full Post: Simple checklist cuts accidental deaths in surgery

Site Navigation

Most Read