Messages often muddled in doctor-patient talks

By Anne Harding

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Doctor-patient communication can be fraught with misunderstanding, a new study confirms.

After 74 meetings between people with severe arthritis of the knee and physicians to discuss treatment, nearly 20 percent of the time, the patient and physician disagreed on whether or not the doctor had recommended knee replacement surgery.

“That’s pretty telling. That’s disturbing,” Dr. Richard L. Street, Jr., of Texas A&M University in College Station told Reuters Health. Often, Street noted, patients and physicians simply take it for granted that they understand one another, but the findings make it clear this isn’t always the case.

When deciding to go through with a procedure like knee replacement, which carries risks and also requires extensive rehabilitation, it’s crucial that the patient and doctor be “on the same page,” Street said. To investigate this, Street and his team recruited 74 patients with knee osteoarthritis that was severe enough to warrant total knee replacement. The patients met with one of 27 health care providers to talk about their care.

There was “modest to poor” agreement between the doctors and the patients after the meetings on how severe the patient’s osteoarthritis was and on the risks and benefits of knee replacement, the researchers found. Usually, physicians thought the patient’s osteoarthritis was less severe than the patient did.

In 13 cases, or 18 percent, the doctor and patient disagreed on whether the physician had recommended knee replacement surgery.

They also found that doctors typically considered complications of the surgery to be less of a concern than patients did.

The stronger the agreement between patient and doctor on the benefits of knee replacement, the more satisfied the patients were and the greater their intention of following the doctor’s recommendations.

Miscommunication isn’t limited to discussions about this type of surgery, but is everywhere in health care, Street said in an interview. For patients, he added, the findings have two key implications. “It’s real important for patients to share their viewpoints,” he said. “If they have concerns they’ve got to be explicit about those, if they’ve got an opinion or preference they need to get that out on the table.”

Also, Street added, patients should “check for understanding” by repeating back what the physician is telling them (for example, “So what you’re telling me is …”).

The take-home message for doctors, Street added, is “don’t assume anything. What they need to do is check for understanding themselves.”

SOURCE: Arthritis & Rheumatism, January 15 2009.


Related Posts:

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Poor mental health before joint replacement surgery may predict less satisfaction afterward, according to a study from Canada. In the Journal of Rheumatology, Dr. Rajiv Gandhi and colleagues from the University of Toronto, note that the incidence of patient-reported dissatisfaction after total joint arthroplasty can be up to 30 percent. In the

Full Post: Mental health linked to joint replacement satisfaction

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Doctors are often reluctant to discuss a seriously ill patients’ uncertain prognosis with family members, but a new study suggests that most families want doctors to address the patients’ uncertain outlook openly and candidly. “The vast majority of families of critically ill patients want physicians to openly discuss the prognosis, even

Full Post: Most families want doctors to be candid

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Primary care doctors in the United States feel overworked and nearly half plan to either cut back on how many patients they see or quit medicine entirely, according to a survey released on Tuesday. And 60 percent of 12,000 general practice physicians found they would not recommend medicine as a career. “The whole thing

Full Post: Many doctors plan to quit or cut back: survey

By Lisa Richwine GAITHERSBURG, Maryland (Reuters) - A U.S. advisory panel has unanimously backed a new version of a Genzyme Corp injection to relieve knee pain from osteoarthritis. The panel of experts voted 5-0 on Tuesday to urge the Food and Drug Administration to approve Synvisc-One, a single-dose formulation of the company’s Synvisc injection. The FDA usually

Full Post: U.S. advisers back Genzyme therapy for knee pain

By Maggie Fox, Health and Science Editor WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Surgeons have replaced 80 percent of a woman’s face, transplanting bone, teeth, muscle and nerve in the first such operation in the United States. They said the woman suffered severe trauma that cost her an eye, much of her nose and her upper jaw and left her

Full Post: First U.S. patient gets face transplant

Site Navigation

Most Read