No evidence seen for benefits of “raw milk”

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Despite significant improvements in animal hygiene over the past several decades, unpasteurized milk can still be contaminated with germs that make people sick, researchers warn in a report in the journal Food Safety.

In recent years, raw milk advocates have claimed that pasteurizing milk destroys beneficial organisms, and that unpasteurized milk is safe and can actually prevent and treat heart disease, cancer and other illnesses, explain Dr. Jeffrey T. LeJeune and Paivi J. Rajala-Schultz of the Ohio State University College of Veterinary Medicine in Columbus.

But in fact, there’s some evidence that disease from raw milk may be on the rise, according to the researchers. From 1973 to 1992, there were an average of 2.4 such outbreaks annually, they note, while from 1993 to 2006 there were 5.2 per year.

“Although some of this increase may be a result of increased detection and reporting, it is clear that disease associated with the consumption of raw milk is still an important public health concern in the United States,” they state.

Pasteurization involves heating milk to destroy disease-causing organisms, and is “the cornerstone of milk safety,” the researchers note. What’s more, they add, there’s no evidence that this process affects the nutritional content of milk.

Cattle-borne diseases, such as brucellosis and bovine tuberculosis, have been virtually eradicated from US cattle, the researchers note. Nevertheless, cows can harbor bugs that are harmful to humans such as E. coli, Salmonella and Listeria without being sick themselves, and the nutrients contained in milk and its neutral pH make it an excellent bacterial breeding ground, LeJeune and Rajala-Schultz explain. While chilling milk can help keep growth of bacteria under control, it can still leave populations of pathogens large enough to make people ill.

Twenty-six states have banned the sale of raw milk, the researchers note, but “various schemes have been developed to make raw milk available to the consumer,” for example selling it as pet food and offering consumers “shares” in cows in return for a supply of raw milk from the animal.

There’s no evidence that raw milk has any health benefits, and it can be harmful, LeJeune and Rajala-Schultz warn, particularly for vulnerable groups such as very young people, ill people, older people and people with impaired immune system function. Even healthy young adults can get sick from drinking raw milk, they add.

They conclude: “Physicians, veterinarians and dairy farmers who promote, or even condone, the human consumption of unpasteurized milk and dairy products may be at risk of subsequent legal action.”

SOURCE: Food Safety, January 1, 2009.


Related Posts:

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - An outbreak of salmonella food poisoning has made 388 people sick across 42 states, sending 18 percent of them to the hospital, U.S. health officials said on Wednesday. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is trying to trace the source of the outbreak, which began in September. The Department of Agriculture,

Full Post: Salmonella outbreak sickens 388 across U.S.: CDC

BEIJING (Reuters) - Three Chinese dairy companies have publicly apologized for their involvement in a toxic milk scandal that has killed at least four children and led to Chinese-made products pulled from shelves around the world. Inner Mongolia Yili Industrial Group, Mengniu Dairy and Bright Dairy Group were found earlier to have produced milk contaminated with

Full Post: China milk scandal companies apologize

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The United States issued an import alert for Chinese-made food products on Thursday, calling for foods to be stopped at the border unless importers can certify they are either free of dairy or free of melamine. Two top U.S. health officials announced they will go to China next week to open food inspection

Full Post: U.S. bans melamine-tainted Chinese dairy products

BEIJING (Reuters) - China is to publish a blacklist of food additives which make products taste better or appear nutritious but are damaging to health, state media said, as it struggles to restore faith in the “made in China” brand. China has weathered a series of health scares in recent months, the most recent being tainted

Full Post: China to draw up blacklist of dangerous ingredients

BEIJING (Reuters) - Over 90 percent of Chinese families with children stricken by toxic milk have taken a state-backed compensation deal, a dairy industry association said, days after a court gave death sentences in the scandal. The China Dairy Industry Association told the official Xinhua news agency late on Friday that families of 262,662 children who

Full Post: China says 90 percent of families take toxic milk deal

Site Navigation

Most Read