Families want doctors to share bad news

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Although many doctors worry about breaking bad news about seriously ill patients to their kin, most family members want to know the truth, a study published Monday suggests.

Research has shown that many doctors hesitate to be fully open with critically ill patients and their families — opting, for example, to give a more optimistic estimate of life expectancy, or to not discuss prognosis at all unless the patient brings it up.

One reason for the reluctance, studies suggest, is that doctors worry about erasing hope for patients and their families.

However, in the new study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine, 93 percent of family members of critically ill hospital patients said that avoiding discussions about prognosis “was not an acceptable way to maintain hope.”

Instead, families said that “timely discussion” about prognosis was essential for them to prepare, emotionally and practically, for the possibility that their loved one would die.

According to Latifat Apatira and colleagues at the University of California, San Francisco, the study supports the belief that doctors should help families “hope for the best and prepare for the worst.”

The findings are based on interviews with 179 family members of seriously ill intensive-care patients; all had been placed on a ventilator because they could not breathe on their own.

When asked, the vast majority of family members said that withholding prognostic information was unacceptable. Only six study participants thought that doctors should do so if they thought the prognosis would be emotionally damaging to the family or further harm the patient’s health.

The findings, Apatira’s team writes, show that family members generally feel they are “resilient enough to hear news of a poor prognosis and also need this information to begin to come to terms with the possible death of a loved one.”

They say that further studies should look at how doctors can “best balance” the task of being truthful about prognosis while giving families the emotional support they need.

SOURCE: Annals of Internal Medicine, December 16, 2008.


Related Posts:

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Doctors are often reluctant to discuss a seriously ill patients’ uncertain prognosis with family members, but a new study suggests that most families want doctors to address the patients’ uncertain outlook openly and candidly. “The vast majority of families of critically ill patients want physicians to openly discuss the prognosis, even

Full Post: Most families want doctors to be candid

LONDON (Reuters) - People caring for family members with dementia commonly abuse them with behavior such as swearing and shouting, researchers said on Friday in a study that shows a more widespread problem than previously thought. “The study shows abusive behavior is very common and not something doctors are regularly asking about and therefore finding,” Claudia

Full Post: Family abuse of people with dementia common: study

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Many newly diagnosed cancer patients, no matter what their age, have trouble absorbing all the information their doctors give them, a new study shows. The findings, which appear in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, refute the notion that patients’ ability to remember medical information is simply a matter of age. Researchers found

Full Post: Cancer patients often forget details of doctor visit

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Smokers whose family members have had a type of bleeding stroke are six times more likely to suffer the same fate than people without these risk factors, according to a new study. The stroke type known as an “aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage” — essentially a burst blood vessel in the brain —

Full Post: Smoking ups brain-bleed risk with family history

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Rather than being an abrupt action, withdrawal of life support often occurs in a sequential or “stuttering” fashion over a period of time, such that the whole process takes longer than a day, according to a new study. Once someone is determined to be brain dead, there is no medical reason

Full Post: Withdrawal of life support often stepwise

Site Navigation

Most Read



  • kinwrite.com@gmail.com